• Anxiety & Depression Series
    • Finding Help Now
    • View All Posts
  • Link-Ups
  • Share the Burden
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

Carry on My Heart

Choosing faith over fear in the everyday...

  • Carry on My Heart
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Why Carry on My Heart?
  • Contact Me
  • Resources for anxiety, fear and depression
  • Share the Burden
  • Contributor and Featured
You are here: Home / Anxiety / Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds

Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds

If you’ve stuck around here any amount of time, you know of my history with fear, anxiety, and depression. But I don’t believe I’ve yet mentioned the one little word that has the potential to stir up those emotions quicker than most. Allow me to introduce you to the culprit:

Should. (And a close relative shouldn’t)

I used to believe that I shouldn’t struggle with those emotions, and because of this, I “shoulded” all over myself.

“I shouldn’t have anxiety.”

“I shouldn’t be this way.”

“I’m a Christian, so I should be happy and not depressed.”

These were the words that played on repeat in my head. Every. Day.

One unrealistic should after another heaped itself onto my shoulders until the weight felt so heavy I could barely stand.

I believed the lie that Christianity “should” equate to perfection and, in turn, forgot the whole human aspect of my humanity. I ran with the perspective that I needed to try harder and be a better Christian, but the harder I tried and the more I “shoulded”—yes, we’re saying this is a word today–the anxiety and depression amplified. I felt I “should” be far above all these inconvenient human emotions. 

Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds

Once I discovered how destructive these shoulds were to my emotional health, I consciously worked to speak the truth rather than shoulds to myself. Sure I felt anxious and depressed; I had—and still have—a weakness in this area, but “shoulding” all over myself only made/makes things worse. No wonder I felt so anxious with shoulds—I was heaping condemnation on myself. God gave us our emotions, and He certainly isn’t blaming us for them. Freedom is found by learning to work with emotions and to stop condemning ourselves for having them.

I am human and flawed. And that’s okay. In fact, it’s not just okay; it’s excellent because God uses imperfect, anxious, flawed things and makes them beautiful! 

Walking away from shoulds

Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds

The should’s I still place on myself

Ever since I began this writing adventure, I’ve felt the pull of what I “should” be writing. (In case you weren’t aware of this, there is a great big blogging world that tells you how “it should” be done.) There are entire sites committed to telling bloggers like me what I should be writing and how to capture people’s attention and stay relevant long enough to hold it. I’ll be honest; I can start to fret over whether or not “I’m doing it right.”

I get caught up in what I think I should be doing instead of what I would like to say, and before I know it, all those “shoulds” work to sidetrack me from my specific goal.

Recently, God reminded me of the “shoulds” I used to heap on myself in my darkest days of anxiety and how I’m still “shoulding” today.

I have found myself back in the old habit of shoulds.

“I should be writing a certain way and on certain topics.”

“I should be doing it like (insert name of another blogger/writer.).”

“I shouldn’t be writing at all; what do I know, I’m not an expert.”

I should; I should, I should…*Cue anxiousness.

How easily old habits resurface when our focus shifts to the world and away from the truth.

Keeping it Simple and walking away from shoulds

I started my blog to share a burden in two ways:

  • To offload the one I carry.
  • And to pick yours up.

Simple as that.

Why am I sharing all of this with you? Because I don’t ever want to forget the beauty God created out of the hard places in me. I don’t want to miss my specific purpose. I don’t want to lose the meaning in pain or be anyone other than who He made me be.

And also; because I’m still on this journey with you. The “should’s” still bring me down and have the ability to make me anxious—I’m not here to give you a polished version of me. But instead, a recovering chronic worrier that clings daily to His grace. I’m not perfectly mended, but working instead to be transparent in the process of my life and writing journey. And through this, I pray you will receive a gift of hope and comfort for your journey.

We are all in this crazy, beautiful life together. And maybe I can help you with the comfort Jesus gave me. 

Sharing Shoulds to break free from anxiety

So, rather than focusing solely on what is happening in the world today—and I know a lot is going on—or the next significant blogging trend on Pinterest, I will continue to keep it simple and share another piece of my healing journey. My story is simple, but aren’t most beautiful things simple? Our savior came simply, with a humble birth and a modest life. And that simple life is the most beautiful story ever told.

Stick around these next few weeks while I talk about the shoulds that held me down and how I choose daily to break free from them.

You’re going to should on yourself—but it’s entirely within your power to decide which shoulds stay and which ones go. You can live in freedom from anxiety’s control and the unnecessary, unrealistic shoulds that hold you down. But if that all feels like a bit too much today, maybe start with this little reminder from a fellow “shoulder”: you have permission to be human.


I am praying today that by sharing the burden on my heart, it will lift the one from yours.

As always, friend, thank you for stopping by,

Feel free to Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Tweet
Pin64
Share
64 Shares
«
»

Anxiety, Depression

Comments

  1. Lisa notes... says

    August 10, 2022 at 11:28 pm

    So many of us are familiar with what it feels like to “should” all over ourselves, including me. Thank you for this encouragement to drop it. I’m glad you linked up at Grace & Truth. I’ll be featuring your post this Friday on my blog in case others didn’t get around to reading it last week!

    Loading...
    • Susan McIlmoil says

      August 11, 2022 at 5:53 pm

      You’re welcome, Lisa, and thank you so much for featuring this post. I’m so glad it was a blessing to you this week!

      Loading...
  2. Aritha says

    August 8, 2022 at 6:19 pm

    Good words. Thank your so much. I especially notice that when I’m tired, fear lurks. That’s difficult. But then I kindly say to myself that it’s not weird.

    Loading...
    • Susan McIlmoil says

      August 8, 2022 at 8:31 pm

      Aritha, thank you for stopping by and commenting. Boy, I can so relate to what you said about being tired! When I am overtired and have too much on my plate, my mind is much more anxious and “busy.”

      Loading...
  3. Janet Salazar says

    August 8, 2022 at 5:01 pm

    I so identify with what you wrote. And it brought to mind the Pharisees of Jesus’ day. They were so distracted by the shoulds, they missed Jesus. I have to remind myself daily to keep my focus on Jesus and not let the shoulds derail me.

    Loading...
    • Susan McIlmoil says

      August 8, 2022 at 8:29 pm

      What a great point, Janet! I love that. It’s so true that we have to turn our focus back to Jesus and away from all the shoulds that hold us down daily.

      Loading...
  4. Donna B says

    August 5, 2022 at 8:11 pm

    Love your words! I often struggle with anxiety and the culprit is more often than not the “shoulds”. How empowering to set those side and walk forward in freedom. Thank you for your encouraging words today, I needed the reminder!

    Loading...
    • Susan McIlmoil says

      August 5, 2022 at 9:33 pm

      Thank you, Donna! It’s amazing to me how often “shoulds” are at the root of my anxiety. I’m so glad you can relate and that this was encouraging to you today!

      Loading...
  5. Lauren Sparks says

    August 5, 2022 at 7:53 pm

    My shoulds are different, but I am finding rest from letting go of mine as well. Thank you for sharing this with Grace and Truth.

    Loading...
    • Susan McIlmoil says

      August 5, 2022 at 9:31 pm

      Yep, Lauren, I have so many different kinds of shoulds that I struggle with. I feel like new ones pop up all the time. Thank you for stopping by!

      Loading...

Social

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Recent Posts

  • Unseen Scars, Unspoken Grace: The Death of a Church, The Hope of Christ June 10, 2025
  • Walking In Peace: Trading Worry for Prayer and Action February 23, 2025
  • Towards the Land: An eternal covenant and gift for today November 25, 2024
  • The end of something Good and the beginning of something beautiful November 1, 2024
  • How to Share the Burden of Mental Health September 22, 2024

Categories

  • Anxiety
  • Anxiety & Depression Series
  • Depression
  • Faith
  • Family
  • Homeschooling
  • Motherhood

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Follow me on Pinterest!

carryonmyheart

Following Jesus | Helping Others Choose Faith over Fear | Writer ✍🏻 | Faith Blogger | Anxiety Fighter | Fire 🔥 Wife | #boymom | Lover of Words |

December 21st, three days before Christmas, marked December 21st, three days before Christmas, marked the winter solstice for the Northern Hemisphere, the shortest day and the longest night. Although Christmas is said to be the “best time of the year,” winter can feel brutal for those struggling with the dark, frigid months and many battle with grief more at Christmas than at other times of the year. 

Perhaps grief and loneliness feel closer to you than anyone else this Christmas or maybe your world feels more fearful than faith-filled even though people surround you. If this is your struggle today, you are sincerely not alone.

We may be in the darkest, coldest time of the year—and perhaps you are in your darkest season—but Christmas day reminds us of the promise that the Light is coming to stay. One day, Jesus will return to end the endless winter and darkest night, not as a helpless baby but as a conquering king.

The celebration of Christmas isn’t just the fact that He once came; It is that He has promised to return. No matter how dark the night or cold the hour, His Light shines over the horizon.

Friend, keep faithfully looking to the dawn on the horizon where the Light is and where your hope stands firm. Fear not; this winter won’t last forever, which is reason enough to rejoice this Christmas.

Merry Christmas. ❤️
Full devotion at Crossmap.com (link in bio)
Artza means towards the land. I will bless those Artza means towards the land.

I will bless those who bless you… and all the families of the earth shall be blessed through you… and they went out towards the Land”
Genesis 12:3-5

Artza has been on a mission since they began to strengthen your connection to the Holy Land and the stories of the Bible by bringing the bounty of Israel to your door.

Each beautifully crafted box is from a different region of the holy land and supports the businesses, artisans and families that call Israel home. They bring the Holy land toward you when you can’t go in person. 🫶🏼

✨Click the link to visit Artza and enter code Susan20 for 20% off. 
https://www.artzabox.com/

#ad #artza #israel
I haven’t “introduced” myself in quite a while, an I haven’t “introduced” myself in quite a while, and I know how it is to follow a Social account, forget I followed it, and then see something pop up and wonder who it’s from and when I started following them. (Full disclosure: This has been known to happen within one day.)🤷🏻‍♀️

So, here goes: Hi 👋🏼 I’m Susan. I’m a writer, blogger, extroverted introvert, worrier, fear fighter, anxiety survivor, believer in Jesus, encourager, wife, mom, daughter, sister, aunt and friend. 

* I write words that encourage and uplift. A few years ago, I started my blog, carryonmyheart, because writing helped me process and get everything inside my head “out.”

* The name of my blog contains the last words my grandma spoke to my family and me. You can click on the link in my bio if you’re curious about that. ❤️

* I’ve been blessed to have my writing published, a dream I never thought possible.

* I’m a very private person, so writing words that go out into the world is not easy or comfortable for me, but I feel it’s essential for a few reasons: I write to tell my story, talk about Jesus, and make sense of the nonsensical. I write to encourage others who battle with fear, anxiety, panic, depression and wrestle with faith because I know what it feels like to think you’re alone in that struggle.

* I have four brothers, married someone who has 6 brothers and I have 3 sons. No sisters or daughters but I’ve been blessed with wonderful sister-in-laws and amazing nieces. ❤️

* I’ve been married for 25 years to a firefighter. I have three sons; one is in Army basic training, one just graduated college, and the last is in high school and going through driver’s Ed. ( I AM SO THANKFUL this is the last kid I have to teach to drive!)😅

* My favorite thing to do is laugh and I’m drawn to funny people. I have amazing girlfriends that bring me so much joy. We get together and do ridiculous things (like taking prom pictures ), and laugh so hard our faces hurt. 

* And lastly, I have the cutest dog and cat. The older I get, the more I love my animals. I think my phone has more pictures of them than my kids. 😂

Is there anything you can relate to? I’d love to know. 🥰
I know not every ending is good, and not every beg I know not every ending is good, and not every beginning is beautiful—there is a portion of pain in most endings and even some beginnings. But I know God finds us, walks with us, and loves us best in the things that hurt, change, end, and begin.

Sometimes, we hold so tightly to the ending that we miss the beautiful beginning just around the corner. I pray today that we’ll look past the ending and see what God has in store over the horizon.

Read more: link in bio ✨

#carryonmyheart #christianblogger #faithblogger #encouragementwriter #faithwriter
I guess this is my cue that I’m done writing for t I guess this is my cue that I’m done writing for the day 🤷🏻‍♀️🥰😆 The minute they see me sit down in a comfortable spot to write they assume I’ve made them a bed. 

(To all you writers or people that work from home: do your animals do this?!) 

#carryonmyheart #faithwriter #encouragementwriter #faithbloggers #faithblogger
One week ago, our Logan left for basic training. H One week ago, our Logan left for basic training. He took the last couple of weeks off of work before leaving to spend time with family, friends, and his beloved old truck, which he’s worked hard to finish. 😂

I’m so thankful for that precious time with him before he left. We did things every day, like running errands, where we could spend time talking about life. We went to the zoo as a family—something we did often when the boys were little—and took a vacation with family, where we ate good food and laughed a lot. Finally, our beautiful family and friends who love him big came and covered him in hugs, kisses and prayer. 

Then, the day I was dreading came: we drove to the airport; I hugged him tight, reminded him to eat and be safe, and watched him walk through TSA while I spilled warm, salty tears. That drive home was the quietest drive we’ve ever taken.

Six days after he’d gone, I got a surprise FaceTime call from a soldier who looked a lot like my son. We patched Dad in, who was at the fire department, so Loges could show off his dog tags and shaved head and share that he had taken a trip to the emergency room. But he’s okay. 

“He’s okay.” It’s what I whisper these days—more like holy words, spilling out as prayer while I pass by his too-quiet bedroom.

Yes, it’s “just” basic training, and he’ll be back. But let me tell you: as I watched him walk through those metal detectors and disappear among the throngs of people, I knew then that life would never entirely be the same. 

Something ended. Something began. 

This kid has always had the heart of a servant. I knew from the time he was five or six that he would do something selfless. It’s just in his nature. And I’ve been holding my breath ever since.

I am beyond proud of this young man and the servant’s heart he possesses, but boy, is it hard on my heart. I miss him. Period. I can’t wait to give him the biggest hug when I see him again. ❤️ 

And also. Please pray for our troops… and their moms. I can safely speak for every military mom; we appreciate it. ❤️🙏🏻

#mysonisarmystrong
(2Corinthians 12:8-9) Paul’s message in this scri (2Corinthians 12:8-9) 
Paul’s message in this scripture is not one of defeat, where we shrug our shoulders and say, “Well, I tried,” No, it’s one of victory! It’s the key to understanding how God’s power is perfected. His strength rests with the weak, the struggling, the poor, and the grieving. The truth we so often forget is that our humanity is what qualifies us to carry God’s power. Jesus granted to us, through the Holy Spirit, the “Divine power” for “All things that pertain to life and godliness.” (2 Peter 1:3)

This world will tell us to overcome, ignore, and banish our weaknesses. However, God tells us to rest in his grace, which is enough for him to do his powerful, perfect work. His strength shines brightest when we finally lay it all down and admit, “I’m weak; I can’t do this.”

The truth is that your weakness can be the most significant conduit of God’s power. Knowing this should cause us to victoriously shout aloud with Paul, “When I am weak, then I am strong!” 

#carryonmyheart #christianblogger #strongandcourageous #powerinweakness
Just incase you or someone you love need this remi Just incase you or someone you love need this reminder today:

I know people have made you feel this way—and most likely even your own mind—but you’re not crazy. I promise. The panic that keeps hammering you and the thoughts that won’t stop spinning has a name: They are panic and anxiety. Again, no, you’re not crazy.

YOU’RE HUMAN. 

#anxiety #panicattacks #hopeforanxiety 
#truthandkindness 

❤️‍🩹link in bio to finish reading
Follow on Instagram
Grace and Truth

Social

  • View Susan Treacy Mcilmoil’s profile on Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Meet Susan

I’m a wife to Don, who happens to be my best friend. I’m also a mama to three wonderful, fun, and dashing young men. I love words and writing, and I love encouraging others to follow Jesus and trust Him with their lives.
Feel free to stay awhile and take a peek around my site!

Reader Favorites

  • 6 Things you need to say to your son
    6 Things you need to say to your son
  • The #1 reason to always say I'm sorry
    The #1 reason to always say I'm sorry
  • Take a "should" inventory
    Take a "should" inventory
  • Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds
    Breaking free from anxiety by walking away from shoulds
  • When a rose blooms in November
    When a rose blooms in November

Subscribe for Updates!

Copyright © 2026 · Darling theme by Restored 316

Loading Comments...
%d